|
Turbo or Supercharger?
Last post Fri, May 18 2012 12:45 by Sven. 30 replies.
-
-
MrChrome


- Forum member since...
Wed, Aug 31 2011
- Somewhere Peaceful.....
- Posts 318

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Rob Morgan:
I have been asking myself this question for ages! I have very little knowledge on FI, all i have ever owned are n/a petrol cars.
I'd like to throw some questions in:
1. which is better £/bhp or are they similar?
2. i'm guessing that a SC would offer better reliability? is this true?
3.what are servicing costs on SC and turbo's? i.e. re-building etc. Please note, i know very little, so i am just going off things i've heard.
The answer to those questions depends on the set-up of supercharger or turbo.... For example, if you fuel either incorrectly then expect them to fail or not be reliable or if you over-boost etc etc...
I've driven quite a few turbo'd MX5s and some are really quick, others are fast but don't have the traditional turbo lag or massive power spike that makes them difficult to drive. However, I remember one that didn't feel any different to a standard car - it just wasn't set-up properly....
Set-up is key....
Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of Truth and Knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods.
Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds.
Logic will get you from A to B. Imagination will take you everywhere..
I'm a Mazda Mender - www.mazdamenders.net
|
|
-
-
-
-
as400


- Forum member since...
Thu, Mar 22 2012
- Surrey
- Posts 16

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Any ideas of a ballpark figure for getting a specialist garage to do the work? Is turbocharging about the same cost as supercharging? What are we talking about £1k £5k £10k?
MK1 1995 1.8 manual
|
|
-
-
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk


- Forum member since...
Wed, Aug 24 2011
- Bishops Stortford, Herts
- Posts 44

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
BBR do a nice kit fitted for about 5 k
Im in the Sunday morning Sideways
1993 Eunos V-special 1.6 Racing Green Miester R coilovers, Larini exhaust, FM2 Turbo (to be fitted)
|
|
-
-
as400


- Forum member since...
Thu, Mar 22 2012
- Surrey
- Posts 16

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Would that be the turbo?...is the supercharger option any cheaper on a 1.8?
MK1 1995 1.8 manual
|
|
-
-
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk


- Forum member since...
Wed, Aug 24 2011
- Bishops Stortford, Herts
- Posts 44

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Thats turboed and they only do turbos. You can get the Jackson Racing super charger from moss europe for around 3k but then you've got to find someone to install it.
I,ve got a second hand flying miata set up from the nutz forum for £1400 and I'm in the process of fitting it myself but as my car is not a daily driver I've got the time to plod along learning as I go.
Performance 5 is a good place to start if you live in the london area they fit both turbos and superchargers.
Im in the Sunday morning Sideways
1993 Eunos V-special 1.6 Racing Green Miester R coilovers, Larini exhaust, FM2 Turbo (to be fitted)
|
|
-
-
bk65


- Forum member since...
Thu, Jun 16 2011
- Rainham, Kent
- Posts 641

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk:
BBR do a nice kit fitted for about 5 k
...and very nice it is too 
BK(Big Kev)...Member of the Grey Brigade and the Buccaneer5 2006 galaxy grey mica mk-3 2.0i sport..BBR-Cosworth supercharged..eibached..s/steel c/back exhaust..ebc t/groove discs..y/stuff pads..subtle bodykit...CW alloys shod with T1-R's Currently re-living my youth in Rainham, Kent
|
|
-
-
Betty_Swallocks


- Forum member since...
Tue, Nov 18 2008
- Peterborough
- Posts 290
|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
bk65:
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk:
BBR do a nice kit fitted for about 5 k
...and very nice it is too 
I should bloody well hope it is for 5 grand
1990 Red NA 1.6 
|
|
-
-
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk


- Forum member since...
Wed, Aug 24 2011
- Bishops Stortford, Herts
- Posts 44

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Betty_Swallocks:
bk65:
stevetkocz@yahoo.co.uk:
BBR do a nice kit fitted for about 5 k
...and very nice it is too 
I should bloody well hope it is for 5 grand
I'm not far off 5 grand doing mine myself but hey thats part of the fun
Im in the Sunday morning Sideways
1993 Eunos V-special 1.6 Racing Green Miester R coilovers, Larini exhaust, FM2 Turbo (to be fitted)
|
|
-
-
bk65


- Forum member since...
Thu, Jun 16 2011
- Rainham, Kent
- Posts 641

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Betty_Swallocks:
I should bloody well hope it is for 5 grand
a bit extravagant i know.....but you can't take it with you ! 
BK(Big Kev)...Member of the Grey Brigade and the Buccaneer5 2006 galaxy grey mica mk-3 2.0i sport..BBR-Cosworth supercharged..eibached..s/steel c/back exhaust..ebc t/groove discs..y/stuff pads..subtle bodykit...CW alloys shod with T1-R's Currently re-living my youth in Rainham, Kent
|
|
-
-
Locke-alike


- Forum member since...
Tue, Nov 11 2008
- saddleworth
- Posts 961

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
i got all my bits for about £1200 and spent £400 getting it fitted (10-12 hours)
£190 getting a good r/road tune.
And it reliable and quick.
I dont think the question should be about which is better, but which suits the way you want the car to drive.
Alan
 Max5 Mk3 race car 42 sponsored by http://www.brynhilton.co.uk/ www.masbars.co.uk
|
|
-
-
MX5 Paul


- Forum member since...
Wed, Dec 16 2009
- Norwich Norfolk
- Posts 300

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
Just checked this out on the link, sounds awsome, is it a 1.8 or 1.6?? I have been thinking about this for a while. I have a early 1.6. What sort of cost is there?
I use my car as a daily driver/trackday car. Have bittten by the trackday bug. Just bought a set of Federal R-SR's for blyton. Looking forward to it.
Paul
1.8 VT Sport 2.5 1.6 Eunos Mariner Blue
|
|
-
-
kevallen


- Forum member since...
Fri, Nov 14 2008
- Norwich
- Posts 1,146

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
MX5 Paul:
Just checked this out on the link, sounds awsome, is it a 1.8 or 1.6?? I have been thinking about this for a while. I have a early 1.6. What sort of cost is there?
I use my car as a daily driver/trackday car. Have bittten by the trackday bug. Just bought a set of Federal R-SR's for blyton. Looking forward to it.
Paul
I see you are still hankering for some extra horses, Paul.
2001 Mazdaspeed & 1991 MK1 Lemon
|
|
-
-
Locke-alike


- Forum member since...
Tue, Nov 11 2008
- saddleworth
- Posts 961

|
Re: Turbo or Supercharger?
MX5 Paul:
Just checked this out on the link, sounds awsome, is it a 1.8 or 1.6?? I have been thinking about this for a while. I have a early 1.6. What sort of cost is there?
I use my car as a daily driver/trackday car. Have bittten by the trackday bug. Just bought a set of Federal R-SR's for blyton. Looking forward to it.
Paul
Is that directed at Me? if so then yes ita a 1.8
a home brew kit of a hundred seperate peices..well almost
http://www.mx5oc.co.uk/forum/forums/t/21762.aspx
gives the background
If you have just started doing trackdays do you need the extra power?
I only fitted it because id get held up by RX8's in the corners then the would poon me down the straights...not now they don't
Both Uma and the race car will be at the Blyton Bash so I can take people out and they can get a sense of what the car does different from a standard one.
Once ive got the brakes bled and feeling firmer.
see you then maybe?
Alan
 Max5 Mk3 race car 42 sponsored by http://www.brynhilton.co.uk/ www.masbars.co.uk
|
|
|
|
|